Luke 9:19
They answering said, John the Baptist; but some say, Elias; and others say, that one of the old prophets is risen again.
Luke 9:19 (KJV)
Context
In Luke 9, Jesus had just sent out His twelve disciples, giving them authority over unclean spirits and power to heal diseases. They went throughout the villages, preaching the kingdom of God and healing the sick. Later in the chapter, Jesus feeds the multitude with five loaves and two fishes. Afterward, Jesus asks His disciples a crucial question, leading to their response in verse 19.
Meaning
Jesus asks His disciples, “Whom say the people that I am?” This question probes the people’s perception and understanding of Jesus’ identity. It gives an opportunity for the disciples to express what they have observed and heard from the people.
In response, the disciples share the different opinions held by the people. Some said, “John the Baptist,” while others believed He was “Elias” (Elijah). Yet, there were those who thought He was “one of the old prophets risen again.” These answers reflect the diverse views circulating among the people regarding Jesus’ identity.
Some believed Jesus was John the Baptist because of the similarities between them. Both John and Jesus preached repentance and the coming kingdom of God. John the Baptist had been beheaded earlier by Herod, but some thought that he had returned in the person of Jesus. This view also echoes Herod’s own wonder in Luke 9:7, where he heard of Jesus’ works and questioned whether John had risen from the dead.
The mention of Elias (Elijah) suggests that some people believed Jesus was a prophet, possibly the fulfillment of the prophecy in Malachi 4:5-6, where it is foretold that Elijah would return before the coming of the Messiah. This expectation was common in first-century Judaism, as Elijah was highly revered and expected to play a role in God’s redemptive plan.
The third response indicates that people considered Jesus to be a prophet in the same vein as the prophets of old, such as Isaiah, Jeremiah, or one of the other prophets who had risen again. This shows that the people were aware of prophetic traditions and expected a prophetic figure to reappear.
Biblical connections
The disciples’ answers indicate that the people had a range of opinions about Jesus’ identity, but all of them fell short of recognizing Him as the Christ. This sets the stage for Peter’s confession in verse 20, where he declares, “Thou art the Christ of God,” affirming Jesus’ true identity as the Messiah, the anointed one of God. The contrast between human speculation and divine revelation is central here: true knowledge of Jesus’ identity comes not from popular opinion but from God’s revelation.
Application
This verse challenges readers to consider their own understanding of Jesus. Popular opinions about Him may be varied and even respectful, but they are insufficient. Like Peter, each person must move beyond hearsay to a personal confession of faith in Jesus as the Christ. The question Jesus asked His disciples remains relevant: who do you say that I am?
Reflection
The people’s guesses, though earnest, were incomplete. They saw Jesus as a prophet, but He is far more. This passage invites believers to rest in the certainty of divine revelation rather than the shifting opinions of the crowd, and to confess with confidence that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of the living God.

